×


Home About Contribute Media Kit Contact Sign In
×







.


Legal Industry News

Clarion champions improved hourly rates for Court of Protection lawyers


Leeds law firm Clarion has helped to win a landmark case that will result in a significant change to national guideline hourly rates for Court of Protection lawyers. After 10 years with no pay rise, the judgment has been widely welcomed by professionals throughout the UK.

Clarion champions improved hourly rates for Court of Protection lawyers


"This outcome is very welcome news for COP practitioners, providing overdue ratification for the vital work they conduct. "
Stephanie Kaye



Following a Hearing on 26 May 2020, the judgment by Master Whalan was handed down today (30th September), indicating a 20% increase to the rates payable in Court of Protection (COP) cases, following a case supported by Stephanie Kaye who heads up Clarion’s Court of Protection Costs team.

 

The case was brought by four professional deputies from four different law firms, namely Wrigleys Solicitors, Freeths LLP, Boyes Turner LLP and Gillhams Solicitors, who acted collectively to bring the issue before the Senior Courts Costs Office, highlighting that the Guideline Hourly Rates (GHR) had not changed for 10 years, but factors like inflation, increasing workload and growing responsibility on professional deputies, had caused concern about the sustainability of Court of Protection work. Clarion prepared the four bills of costs for submission, claiming the GHR of 2010 plus a percentage uplift to reflect RPI inflation (of approximately 31%) between 2010 and 2019.

 

Stephanie comments: “This outcome is very welcome news for COP practitioners, providing overdue ratification for the vital work they conduct. Importantly, the outcome will mean that this crucial area of work continues to be sustainable.

 

“We are proud to have been a part of this case. We will be applying the 20% uplift to all cases going forward to ensure COP lawyers recover their fair rates, and are happy to revise existing bills which have not yet been assessed to reflect the changes.”

 

A Directions Hearing took place on 17 April 2020 and the parties were asked to produce evidence in support of the claim. All four deputies, Clarion and additional resources from willing members of the Professional Deputies Forum produced evidence, further reinforcing that the 2010 rates were not fit for purpose.

 

Richard Wilcock of Exchange Chambers represented the parties at the Final Hearing, and relied on the  relevant factors in the Civil Procedure Rules, the GHR Review Committee and recent case law in his submission, all pointing to the fact that changes to the rates payable were essential. He made two key arguments; the first being that COP work is specialised, combined with the fact that deputies carry, in general, higher overheads, including increasing overhead time, which should mean that the current rates are paid with an uplift. His second argument was presented as an alternative solution, in that if the SCCO wanted to rely on the GHR as a starting point, then it must apply an empirical uplift to reflect the incidence of inflation between 2010 and 2019.

 

Due to inconsistencies in the evidence produced relating to overheads, Master Whalan was not convinced by the first argument. He said that the findings “do not, in my view, demonstrate that the burden is one that is exclusive to COP work or that it is atypically high in comparison with that experienced by practitioners in comparable areas of practice.” He confirmed that the approach set out in Re: Smith and others [2007] and Yazid Yahiaoui and others [2014] was still correct and applicable.

 

Maser Whalan then moved on to Counsel’s secondary argument. He emphasised that he had no power to review the GHR, but recognised that they couldn’t provide “reasonable remuneration unless these rates are subject to some form of periodic, upwards review.” Importantly, Master Whalan states in his judgment, “I do not merely express some empathy for Deputies engaged in COP work, I recognise also the force in the submission that the failure to review the GHR since 2010 threatens the viability of work that is fundamental to the operation of the COP and the court system generally.”

 

On the topic of inflation, Master Whalan questioned whether CPI was more appropriate than RPI. He  said “I am satisfied that in 2020 the GHR cannot be applied reasonably or equitably without some form of monetary uplift that recognises the erosive effect of inflation”. He further specifies that “If the hourly rates claimed fall within approximately 120% of the 2010 GHR, then they should be regarded as being prima facie reasonable” and provides a suitable table of the GHR with a 20% uplift to assist the Costs Officers undertaking future COP assessments:

 

 

Guideline Hourly Rates

Bands      A                B               C           D

London 1 £490          £355          £271     £165

London 2 £380          £290          £235     £151

London 3 £275-320   £206-275   £198    £145

National 1 £260         £230          £193     £142

National 2 £241         £212          £175     £133

 

Master Whalan concludes by saying that the rates above are applicable to all outstanding assessments, regardless of the year the work was undertaken. He also advised that the recommendations of the GHR Working Group must be adopted in preference to his findings.

.


Legal Business News - A North East property lawyer has used her own conveyancing skills to move into new offices with a historical link her to her profession. Sue Toomey has moved her Toomey Legal practice to Cramlington Village where she has taken over the Surveyors House which first appeared in maps of the town in the mid 1800s.


Property Legal Firm Moves into Historic Property

Legal Business News - Sheffield based digital agency The SEO Works have been selected to develop an SEO strategy for one of the UK s leading personal injury brands The Compensation Experts, part of the mmadigital group of companies.


The Compensation Experts appoint SEO Works

Legal Business News - Celsus Group sources medical talent and services to both the public and private healthcare sectors including primary care providers, NHS hospitals and local authorities and is also one of the UK s leading providers of locum GPs. Celsus Group will be one of the latest additions to Sullivan Street s portfolio.


Gateley Legal advises on the sale of Celsus Group to Sullivan Street Partners

Legal Business News - The corporate team at Gateley Legal have advised leading HR technology company ELMO, on its acquisition of UK-based HR platform, Breathe - a fast-growing, market leading self-service HR platform for small businesses.


Gateley Legal advises ELMO Software Limited on the acquisition of Breathe

Legal Business News - Taking up the position of legal director with Clarion, Parul has 20 years experience in commercial property, acting for both private and public sector clients. Parul has spent the last 15 years working for an international law firm, based at its Leeds office.


Another legal director joins Clarions Real Estate team as demand continues

Legal Business News - Women in the Law UK is to host its annual conference online on Friday 20 November. The event, which will be held via Zoom, will take the theme, Empowering you to do what you do best and unlocking your talent.


Women in the Law UK to hold annual conference via Zoom next month